Watch 2010 UK sites

Shobdon Church
Nominator: Church of England - Hereford Diocese
Location: Shobdon, Herefordshire
Period of significance: 13th and 18th centuries
Main issues: Structural movement, small parish community
Shobdon, in Herefordshire, is wonderfully remote. Its church is listed Grade I, sitting within a rural landscape of notable historic value. The earliest fabric in the church building is its 13th century tower, but the nave and chancel were rebuilt in the 1750s in a Rococo-infused ‘Gothick’ style, an ecclesiastical outpost of Strawberry Hill, Twickenham. Its design thought to be heavily influenced by Richard Bateman, a friend of Walpole. But for its modern sugared-almond colour scheme, it survives as designed and constructed and as an authentic and integral whole.
As with all parish churches the building is cared for by the local community but Shobdon is well-known enough to have influenced churches abroad, including one modern example in Virginia.
What is not so clear is how the building was constructed. A stockpile of reused beams and planks appears to have been incorporated into the masonry walls and internal framing during its 18th century conversion. Now these timbers are rotting resulting in significant and damaging movement that will be expensive to repair and require deconstruction of parts of the church. In a general sense, this is yet another example of the plight of many parish churches nationwide which depend upon the commitment of volunteer parishioners for their survival.

Sheerness Dockyard
Nominator: SAVE Britain’s Heritage
Location: Isle of Sheppey, Kent
Period of significance: 17th and 19th centuries
Main issues: Commercial pressure, isolation, disparate ownership
Sheerness Naval Dockyard encompasses two Scheduled Ancient Monuments, one Grade I, more than twenty Grade II* and eleven Grade II listed structures. Positioned at a strategic point at the mouth of the rivers Thames and Medway, Sheerness has long played an important role in our naval defences. Samuel Pepys proposed the first dockyard in 1665, later destroyed by the “Dutch Raid” of 1667. After the Napoleonic wars the dockyard was completely rebuilt as a planned town, in one phase of construction, to the designs of John Rennie.
Now a Royal Navy Dockyard, warships were stocked and repaired at Sheerness until its closure in 1960. The twentieth century contributed World War II and cold war structures including a now disused nuclear bunker.
Sadly the site has recently fragmented into ownership by different parties with separate agendas. As a result some of the most significant buildings lie within the bounds of a commercial port, remain unused and are decaying. Elsewhere highly inappropriate changes and redevelopments are currently being proposed which threaten two complete and virtually unaltered Georgian terraces. The most immediate opportunity is to significantly raise the profile of Sheerness, support a strong local and national conservation campaign, and therefore to deflect inappropriate planning applications whilst promoting a sustainable and careful pattern of ownership and usage.

Tecton Buildings at Dudley
Zoological Gardens
Nominator: The Twentieth Century Society
Location: Dudley, Worcestershire
Period of significance: 1930s
Main issues: partially redundant use, historic lack of maintenance
Constructed between 1935 and 1937 around a wooded medieval motte surmounted by a castle, Dudley Zoo represents the only collection of interrelated designs at one site by Berthold Lubetkin’s practice, Tecton. The design of the Dudley Zoo ensemble, unique in the UK and rare within Europe, consists of 12 reinforced concrete animal display “houses” and pavilions, juxtaposed against a natural setting. It dramatically communicates the interrelationships of artistic, social, civic, research and natural values which typify the early (British) Modernist movement.
Over time and due to changing zoological practice, the design of the zoo has been adversely affected by disuse of some Tecton structures by newer constructions in other areas and by the alteration of the natural, wooded, setting into a more manicured garden environment. However its uniqueness and integrity warrant inclusion on the Watch. When the zoo was opened in May 1937 it was so popular that 250,000 people attempted to visit in one single day: that enthusiasm is sought anew through championing conservation-minded refurbishment.
Lubetkin’s work at Dudley Zoo is currently underappreciated; we hope any proposal will consider the twelve Tecton structures as a single piece of work rather than as individual buildings.

Edinburgh Historic Graveyards
Nominator: The City of Edinburgh Council
Location: Edinburgh, Midlothian
Period of significance: 16th - 19th century
Main issues: exposure to elements, vandalism in an urban environment
These five historic graveyards all lie within the heart of the World Heritage Site of central Edinburgh. In 1581 the Church of Scotland forbade burials with churches resulting in these distinctive spaces often containing family mausoleums used by successive generations. Now they are oases of calm within the crowded city streets and commercial and residential premises.
The sculpture present in the cemeteries records the development of architectural styles in Scotland and is testament to the craft traditions which created them. The stones and monuments also record the transition of Edinburgh from a medieval burgh in the early 18th century through the enlightenment and to becoming the second city of Empire in the late nineteenth century. Many prominent Scottish individuals and families are buried here and so there are certainly strong community attachments that remain.
However in some instances the cemeteries have become known for negative reasons, as an unsafe environment home to illicit activities. The general condition of the funerary monuments is poor and in many instances headstones have been pushed over and fractured or have been set down for safety reasons. However, aside from their heritage value, these are wonderful inner-city urban spaces that deserve to be reclaimed for everyone. A comprehensive plan that brings together diverse stakeholders towards a common end is urgently needed.

Russborough, Ireland
Nominator: The Alfred Beit Foundation
Location: Blessington, Co. Wicklow, Ireland
Period of significance: 18th century
Main issues: inadequate income, pressures on landscape management
Russborough is undoubtedly one of the most important eighteenth- century estates in Ireland. More of a palace than a country house, it survives as an almost totally intact architectural ensemble of mansion and designed landscape, against the dramatic backdrop of the Wicklow Mountains. This is a vision of rare integrity which should be protected wherever possible.
Between 1951 and 1976 the estate was owned by the renowned collector Sir Alfred and Lady Beit who later transferred the ownership of the site and their unique art collection to a charitable trust which ensures that the house remains open and accessible to the public. This recent history, and the fact that many local people work at Russborough, ensures that there are strong community attachments to the place. However, income generated from visitors to the site fails to fund the specialist conservation care of the house’s collection and its landscape.
Russborough could benefit from an international awareness of its qualities. But with a necessary focus on increasing visitor income it is important that a suitable balance between conservation and development is reached. WMF is hopeful that inclusion on the Watch will encourage enhanced management of the designed landscape surrounding the property which has not been previously prioritised.
Site Update

Carlisle Memorial Methodist Church, N. Ireland
Nominator: Belfast Building Preservation Trust
Location: Belfast, N. Ireland
Period of significance: 19th century
Main issues: lack of use, serious physical degradation
Carlisle Memorial Methodist Church sits in a highly urbanised area on the edge of inner-city Belfast. Widely recognised as the major landmark for much of the surrounding area the building has significant links to its locality, the city as a whole and it contributes considerably to the historic streetscape.
Built between 1872 and 1875, the church was home to one of the largest and most significant Methodist congregations in Belfast. It was constructed by a native architect, James Carlisle, in memory of his son. Designed in the Gothic Revival style by William Henry Lynn, one of Belfast’s noted architects, it was constructed using a now very unhappy mix of limestone and sandstone.
However this high quality Victorian building has been empty since 1982 and is now in a critical condition after many years of neglect. Another part of the site is used as an Indian community centre and with its location at a major interface between Catholic and Protestant residents any solution for its renovation and reuse will be complex. Having said this, the potential for this building to really contribute to the regeneration of north Belfast is very evident and a priority for WMF and the nominator, the Belfast Building’s Preservation Trust, who have a recognised track record in similar regeneration projects.